Don’t forget to let us know who helped you, what style/flavor cookie you got, or if you enjoyed one of our tasty drinks!
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
These cookies are worth the special stop. Every time I go I try a different one. The iced coffee is incredible and is the perfect pairing with one of these delicious cookies. I just recently tried the Caramel Apple and Boy, was that a life changing first bite. I always enter and leave Schmackary's happy!!
The Foodie Out Loud
Foodie Out Loud
I visited Schmackary's in March of this year and enjoyed your delicious treats. For a birthday party I was throwing for myself on July 5, I ordered 9 dozen cookies to be shipped to San Diego, 2nd day air. My guests were beyond excited with their special dessert. I love chocolate chip cookies and yours are the best. We enjoyed a great assortment of your cookies (sorry, can't even remember which ones we ordered - too much going on) and I couldn't be happier with the decision to order from my hometown of NY. Best wishes.
Coming to Schmackary's has become a ritual whenever I go to NYC. In all the times I've been there, I have found EVERY person to be incredibly kind and outgoing. I can tell that they put extra care into finding the perfect people! The interior is adorable, and always puts me in a great mood. Of course, the best thing about Schmackary's is their DELICIOUS array of sweets! I couldn't have asked for a better shop!
I come in every morning for a almond milk lattè. The old barista left, and was very sceptical about the new barista. But she made my latte perfect. After I enjoyed my almond milk lattè I told her what a perfect lattè she made me. In return she thanked me with a smile. What a sweet girl.
Schmackary's your new staff are the sweetest, I'm happy your growing business is more diverse, I love it. Your barista recommended the key lime cookie to go with my lattè. May I say it was everything! She explained it as is summer had a taste, she nailed that lattè every time I come in. Don't let her go anywhere. Her hospitality is so welcoming. Love her. I look forward to seeing her every morning. Keep up the great work guys.
My sister and I were on vacation and we walked in completely by accident--we read about 5 Napkin Burger online and saw Schmackary's on the way out. It was so good that we came back before our vacation was over! We both loved the Cookies and Cream and Funfetti cookies.
After hearing all the exceptional reviews about these cookies I had to try them on my trip to New York City this past week, and I was completely blown away!! These are BY FAR the best cookies I have ever eaten! I would highly recommend heading over to Schmackary's if you have any doubts in your mind.
It’s absolutely fascinating to see how quickly the name “Schmackary’s” spreads by word of mouth via the theatre community. I had been told for months from several actor friends of mine that I have to try these cookies, but I guess I put it off for awhile. I mean, it’s just a cookie, right? (I am now greatly ashamed of this allegation, sorry Schmacks!). Clearly I was simply in denial. Finally after beginning to feel left out of this glorious land of cookies I decided to try this mysterious place that I’ve heard so much about. Let’s just say I walked in to “just try 1” and left with a dozen for friends and coworkers (but mostly me). My favorite is definitely the funfetti, but I love all that I’ve tried. I like that the cookies change with not only the days of the week but the seasons as well. I’m now always the first to recommend when a friend or family member is in the city.
Lastly I absolutely love the ambiance and feel to the store, and the price is perfect. Even us starving artists can afford these cookies :)
The esteemed Hayley Podschun (Wicked) recommended Schmackary's and trying these cookies for the first time was life changing. The Choconut Chip is the first flavor I tried and it was absolutely divine. I also have had Green Tea (phenomenal), Red Velvet (remarkable), Chocolate Covered Pretzel (astonishing), Fluffer Nutter (extraordinary), Sch'mores (incredible), and Maple Bacon (whimsical)! If you are in NYC this is a MUST on your list - right up there with Times Square, the Empire State Building, etc. When I visit NYC, this is now my very first stop! And when I'm not in NYC - I've been known to order online and have them shipped to me. These are, without a doubt, the best cookies in the world! THANK YOU SCHMACKARY'S!!!!!!!!
My friend and I went to Schmackary's on the recommendation of strangers at a stage door - and now I recommend Schmackary's to EVERYONE!!! People ask "can a cookie place really be that good?" The answer is YES! I love that they're open late, and the variety of flavors is excellent. I always try something new and I haven't been disappointed yet. A trip to New York is not complete without a visit to Schmackary's!!!
Katrina in Seattle
The vegan cookie was DELICIOUS, I'm so sad it's gone! I would totally buy them all the time if they came back. Any vegan cookie at Schmackary's would be awesome... maybe vegan chocolate chip?
These are by far the GREATEST cookies I have ever tried. Every time I make my way into the city, I have to stop by Schmackary's. The people there are always warm and inviting. The coffees are delicious and the cappuccino art is very impressive. The Maple Bacon Cookie and the Ginger Rogers are by far my favorites. Keep up the good work, Schmackary's!
Best cookies ever!
Hands down, the best thing I have ever put in my mouth.
Steven Tylor O'Connor
I came to the city from Florida to take some dance classes at broadway dance center. Your cookies were the best thing after a long day of classes!! They are absolutly the best! The white chocolate cranberry dream is my fave! Thank you for making my time in NY with your awesome desserts.
Today as I walked to work I stopped in for a chocolate duet cookie, cute little cup of coffee, and beautiful blue/white striped flier. Needless to say I ended up on this website, took one look at the menu, and instantly wanted to try EVERYTHING. You guys made my day and I only wish I knew about Schmackary’s sooner! But actually...
My favorite Newsies rave about Schmackary’s so I had to try it out – absolutely awesome! I had the ice cream sandwich with oatmeal scotchies – delish! I will definitiely be ordering to get my fix and try more flavors!
My friends and I were in the mood for a sweet snack and we came across Schmackary’s by chance. I had the key lime cookie. I don’t normally like key lime anything, but this was one of the best cookies I’ve ever had. My friend bought the ‘kitchen sink’ bar. That too was fabulous. I’ll definitely be going back.
I heard about you you guys at the YFC golf outing yesterday. I loved your story so much that 2 ladies and I just had to come to your store for a package. We tried the triple chip. WOW. Your cookies were (and still are!) the best I have EVER eaten...and I am a home baker! My family has nearly devoured the two bags we brought home and I can’t wait to find them in a store near us. Congratulations on a terriffic product and a big THANK YOU for sharing your story!
Absolutely delicious! My son Zachary and I enjoyed five flavors. He especially liked the maple bacon…I loved the oatmeal. Definitely worth the walk and the money! Thanks for making our day so special!
Okay, so Key Lime isn’t the fanciest of desserts but it’s my favorite. When I saw the Key Lime cookie my draw dropped. After I experienced the Key Lime cookie, I must say…hands down, it’s the BEST cookie I’ve ever had in my life! Also, the coffee served at Schmackary’s is the best (I like it better than Blue Bottle). Although their products are the best, the service is EXCEPTIONAL! The staff is extremely friendly and observant. This is such a great place and I’m a huge fan!
Now, I’m not one to normally go online and comment on these types of things but OH MY GOSH- these cookies are SO DAMN TASTY! I’m also not normally a bacon fan, but the maple bacon cookie = phenomonal. The perfect balance of sweet, salty, crunchy and chewy. I was literally taken aback by the first bite because I was shocked by how good it was. Also tried cookies & cream and blueberry crumb cookies…both delicious, but the maple bacon took the cake, or should I say cookie?
Staff was awesome too! So friendly & nice- wish I could stay there all day!
Visited for the 1st time on Saturday with a friend who suggested the maple bacon, hesitant at 1st but after one bite i am in love, will never look at bacon the same again.
These cookies are thebomb.com
Heard about you guys from the Phantom of the Opera cast, so we just had to stop by and try them when we came to NY to see Phantom yesterday. I was hoping you would have a gluten free choice so that I could try your cookies, and was so excited to find out that you had Lemon Poppy and Sweet Corn available that day. As soon as I tried them, I knew I had to stock up and get a whole dozen to enjoy back home! They are AMAZING, buttery, yummy, melt in your mouth and you would never know that they are gluten free! They are the first gluten free cookies I’ve had that I couldn’t tell any difference. I ate 5 of them throughout the day in NY, and they are big! I am planning to take more trips to NY and will definitely be planning a cookie budget so that I can stock up my freezer at home! And the two guys working at the counter were so friendly, welcoming and helpful. Thank you!
Several of my favorite actors from Newsies had raved about this place, so of course, I had to try it. I live close to the city, and now stopping at Schmackary’s is a must every time I go! I usually get a few different cookies, but my favorites are DEFINITELY the original chocolate chip and cookies and cream. The staff is also really kind, and it’s not a far walk from Times Square or 42nd. I’ll be back soon!
Love, love, love the cookies and Schmackary's broadway-bound story. Carrot cake, maple bacon and corn cookies = Amazing!!!! Can’t wait to order online as gifts!
Awesome cookies! The wife and I were introduced to them by a relative that lives in NYC, and they really are amazing. Even though we order them shipped to where we live - they always arrive still moist and very delicious (and when they do arrive they don't hang around too long!). I must be honest and say I have no favorite as all the flavors are just as tasty as the rest! We've even tried the seasonal flavors and those are awesome too - especially the pumpkin ones! Makes me anxious for it to be fall again. A definite must for any cookie-connoisseur, or anyone interested in some really damn good cookies.
I have ordered from Schmackary's a few times now. BEST DARN COOKIES you will EVER find ANYWHERE! These are now my favorite gifts!
I was excited to receive my variety pack. Every cookie was just as delicious as the one before. So fresh. I will definitely order again for myself and for gifts. Yes...they are "Lip-Schmackin' Good Cookies!"
I ordered the variety pack for my birthday and every single cookie was beyond delicious! They were so good I ordered some Schmack Snacks which somehow were even better!
Red Velvet COOKIES?! right?! these are every bit as good as they sound...order some and find out for yourself! Zach has been a great friend for years upon years and, evidently, a talented little baker!! luv you! xoxo
BEST cookies in New York ! Fresh, consistent in flavor, and excellent ordering options. For my 50th this summer it`s all cookies and cupcakes. Looking forward more stores opening soon!!
Scott Jason Miller
The cookies were WONDERFUL. Absolutely delicious and delivered fresh. Everyone at my office loves them and I highly recommend them. I will definitely be ordering more in the future. I ordered the peanut butter and red velvet cookies and both are soooooo good!!
The peanut butter cookies are to DIE for. We fought over the last one!
Also watched your TED Talk--Congrats on growing your business from home to your own store front! It's going to be a huge HIT when you take it across the country!
I sent cookies to friends around the country for the holidays. They arrived when I requested and were a big hit. Besides enjoying them myself they make a great gift.
I ordered them and had them delivered to my hotel the day I was leaving to return to Dallas. I brought them home for my son and daughter. OMG!!! They were amazing!!! It's the best thing I've ever put in my mouth. We had the red velvet and peanut butter and I've never tasted anything so awesome!
Your sweets are the best!
Everybody that I've sent them to has only Delicious things to say about ALL the items.
Keep baking - you have wonderfully delicious treats.
My first time to try Schmackary's and I am a fan.
The cookies and cream are off the hook filled with GOODNESS!!!
The white-chocolate macadamia cookies, they were hard to put down and hide. They are definitely a cure for the common munchies.
the red velvet cookie is amazing.. red velvet cupcakes have some serious competition
Your cookies and cream cookies are CRAZY! They're like perfected Oreo cookies. Like someone deconstructed an Oreo and rebuilt it better than before! It's like the Bionic Woman of Cookies!
You have not fully understood the potential of cookie until you've had a Schmack Snack. Ask for the bacon chocolate chip Schmack Snack. soooooooo goooooooood!
If you have not tried the peanut butter cup cookie, you're missing out on life.
Yes - even Supermodels eat Schmackary's - they are THAT good! In fact, I think I even lose weight eating them!? This recipe is simply D to the LICIOUS...order your Schmackary's for at home or for your next party - but, order more than you think you need because once you try them...you will not want to share!!
Make Me A Supermodel
I live for Schmack-Snacks. Seriously though! Who thought making a cookie denser could make it taste so amazing. <3 I can't wait to have more.
These cookies are so delicious that I just ordered 8 dozen today. I thought I was a cookie expert--I am not the expert, Zach's the expert. I just about wet myself the first time I had one of his cookies. Now, I am like a junkie needing a fix. I need one of those Schmackary's cookies NOW!
You will not believe how incredible they are. You will love them.
I've had Schmackary's. Now any time I eat a Chips Ahoy, I cry.
ZOMG i cannot get enough of these cookies! i discovered Schmackary's a while ago -- the Red Velvet is my favorite. When my order was delivered, they were still warm!! the cookie was perfectly chewy without being mushy, and the frosting was so good... not too sweet or scant. These cookies are so amazing, I ordered them for all my coworkers at MTV during the 2012 VMAs - needless to say, they were gone within minutes and my coworkers have been begging me for more. You will not be disappointed!
so so good!! I was full...but kept eating more. its the kind of cookie that tastes so good you don't want to swallow. you can't go wrong with these cookies!!
Look...I like to eat and I try to do good by the temple...but sometimes being bad can taste so good! I like food that tastes good and is good for you and when I'm gonna cheat by putty something in my mouth that may not be good for my belly I'm gonna eat something that's worth it! When I smack my lips on Schmackary's Cookies I don't care that I may go to hell. I just remind myself that it takes an oven to make these tender bits of goodness so I'm bringing cookies with me!
The only flavor I have tried is the Caramel Apple Crunch, but it seriously blew my mind! I loved it so much, I ordered a dozen for my dad for Father's Day. Can't wait to try the other flavors!
AMAZING! We had the red velvet Schmack-Snacks, and they were decadent! These are perfect for gifts (if you can manage to actually give them away!). ORDER SOME NOW!
Schmackary's are one of a kind! It's refreshing to see a baker offering such new and fresh baking combinations for such a resonable price. And they fit any occasion. You can't eat just one. Well...at least I can't!
Schmackary's cookies were delicious. The shipping was a bit long due to a FedEx problem but even when the cookies arrived they were chewy and "lip-schmackin' good!" I will continue to be an avid customer...
The flavors are really inventive and complex. I'm surprised every time. It's dessert perfected
Schmackary's are SO. FREAKING. GOOD! Seriously, I can't get enough!
I just have to say that I didn't know you could have an orgasm eating a cookie until I put my lips to Schmackary's! I absolutely fell in love with the red velvet cookie and can't get her out of my head. I really hope that we can meet again soon! The point is I feel bad for you if you haven't tasted one of these AMAZING cookies yet!!!!!
You can taste the handmade love-and-care that goes into every cookie and feel it as the smile grows wider and wider across your face! Have you ever wondered what it would be like to bite into something that tastes as good as your birthday, Christmas, New Years, and the 4th of July...combined?! That's SCHMACKARYS! My personal favorite is the Schmack-Snack Peanut Butter Cup. It's 1-part cookie, 10-parts amazing!
Jonathan D. Lovitz
Cookies are an addiction of mine, and Schmackary cookies are my fix. I love the variety and unique flavors of the delectable schmack's. My taste buds go crazy with every bite I take. I recommend the Oatmeal Scothie's and Peanut Butter Cup. Every bite is worth the caloric intake!!!!!
I am a TOTAL sweet tooth - cookies, cakes ... just SUGAR! I must say that Schmackary's cookies are GENIUS! The Schmack Snack is a totally creative - and YUMMY - spin on the traditional cookie. The red velvet cookies are TO DIE for - not me dying, but the person who tries to get close to my cookie! These are a sweet tooth's dream!
Can you say AMAZING!!! I can and will! These are by far the best cookies ever! The Shmack Snack is my favorite; combining the form and texture of a muffin and the taste of a cookie, Pure genius! I can't live without them, good thing I can have them shipped to me and all my friends all over the US!
O.M.G! Scmackary's cookies are so delicious! The Red Velvet cookies were moist, rich, and completely addictive. I've had plenty of oatmeal scotchies, but something about Scmackary's version was amazing! The best Ive ever tasted.
Don't know what his secret is--I'm not convinced their completely legal! Whatever the secret, these cookies will make you very, very happy!!!
Coming from a cookie enthusiast (snob, really), Schmackary's has perfected the art of cookie making, bar none. The creativity, skill and love in each bite leaves these little gems unsurpassed.
Schmackary's cookies are an original. Expect unique yummy flavors. Just thinking about them makes me hungry. They're easy to order and arrive individually wrapped, but just try taking your time to eat them all. They'll call to you, so be forewarned!
I always thought a cookie is just a cookie - what's the big deal with Schmackary's?!?! One bite and I was hooked - moist, flavorful, and delicious! I'm an illusionist and make objects disappear for a living - it's NO ILLUSION that I LOVE making Schmackary's Cookies vanish from the plate... and REAPPEAR in my tummy! Try 'em and see for yourself!
International Star Illusionist
To be honest, I am not a cookie person or should I say wasn't a cookie person till I had Schmackary's. I was on vacation in NYC from Los Angeles and was introduced to them by a friend. I tried a half of one and soon found myself having a few. I am now back in Los Angeles longing for some Schmackary's cookies...LOL I will be having some sent to me via Fedx very soon and thats coming from a guy who isn't a cookie person...WOW AMAZING!!
Don’t forget to let us know who helped you, what style/flavor cookie you got, or if you enjoyed one of our tasty drinks!
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Thank you for your feedback!