Our Flavors

Over 75 Flavors and Counting

Flavors changing often! Be sure to try our "Last Call" flavors before they leave for the season!

Available This Week!

The Classic

semi-sweet chocolate / sea salt

Funfetti

sugar cookie base / rainbow sprinkles / vanilla cream cheese frosting

Cookies & Cream

dark cocoa / white chocolate / oreo bits / vanilla cream cheese frosting

Red Velvet

✔Back in September!

deep red cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / cream cheese frosting

Maple Bacon

LEAVING SOON!

candied bacon / maple syrup / toffee bits / sea salt

Oatmeal Scotchie

oats / butterscotch chips / cinnamon / vanilla

Yogi Bare

gluten free oats / peanut butter / applesauce / cranberries / almonds / sunflower seeds / pumpkin seeds / raisins / maple syrup / cinnamon

The Hummingbird

oats / pineapple / coconut / banana / toasted pecans / southern cream cheese frosting

Chocolate Duet

dark cocoa / white chocolate / semi-sweet chocolate / walnuts

Mystery Cookie

We select a mystery cookie to fill out your flight.

Sch'mores

honey graham base / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted marshmallow

@eatingnyc's Chocolate Crunch

LIMITED TIME FLAVOR

We’ve teamed up with IG’s @eatingnyc for this chocolate crunch cookie delight!
triple chocolate cookie / chocolate nutella frosting / sprinkles / crushed peanuts / sugar cone bits

Hibiscus Strawberry

LEAVING SOON!

hibiscus / cacao nibs / strawberry glaze (vegan)

Cookie Butter Bliss

BACK IN STOCK!

Biscoff cookie butter / brown sugar / cinnamon / vanilla

The Hangover

BACK IN STOCK!

potato chips / walnuts / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / butterscotch / m&ms / raisins / coconut / cinnamon / oats

Dulce de Leche

LEAVING SOON!

caramel fudge / dulce de leche / caramel bites / cinnamon

No Tricks, Just Treats

snickers / butterfinger / reeses pieces / peanut bits / caramel / toffee bits

Peanut Butter Cup

peanut butter / semi-sweet chocolate / roasted peanuts / sea salt

The Peanut Gallery

peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips
*may contain peanuts

Sweet Corn

corn flour / cornmeal / sweet corn / cranberries / pecan bits

Choconut Chip

semi-sweet chocolate / sweetened coconut / walnuts / sea salt

Chocolate Explosion

LEAVING SOON!

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate fudge frosting

Key Lime

LAST CALL – Limited Stock

key lime oil & zest / white chocolate / pistachios / graham cracker / lime cream cheese frosting

Mint Mojito

LAST CALL – limited Stock

corn flour / fresh mint leaves / lime oil / cuban rum glaze

Strawberry Rhubarb

LAST CALL – Limited Stock

strawberries / tart rhubarb / sour strawberry glaze

Carrot Cake

LEAVING SOON!

shredded carrots / sweetened coconut / walnuts / raisins / cinnamon / cream cheese frosting

Chocolate Covered Pretzel

LAST CALL!

dark cocoa / pretzel bits / semi-sweet chocolate / peanut butter chips / sea salt

Green Tea

LEAVING SOON!

matcha green tea / white chocolate / macadamia nuts / green tea glaze

Corny Cowboy

LAST CALL – Limited Stock

sweet corn kernels / bacon / cheddar cheese / diced jalepenos

Peanut Butter Patty

peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / chocolate frosting

Lucky Charmed

LEAVING SOON!

sugar / marshmallows / vanilla / milk & mallow frosting / Lucky Charms cereal

Caramel Apple Crisp

LEAVING SOON!

oats / granny smith apples / white chocolate / toffee bits / cinnamon / salted caramel / streusel

Treats Available Now!

Treats are not currently available. Coming back soon!

Out of Season

BLOOD Red Velvet

deep red cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / cream cheese frosting
*edible blood on local orders only

Candied Yam

NEW FOR OCTOBER!

corn flour / yams / toasted pecans / brown sugar / cinnamon / toasted marshmallow

Peanut Butter After Dark

NEW FOR OCTOBER!

dark cocoa / peanut butter cups / peanut butter chips / semi-sweet chocolate

Pumpkin Spice

NEW FOR OCTOBER!

pumpkin / autumnal spices / cranberries / cinnamon chips / pecans / maple cream cheese frosting

Rosemary's Baby

pine nuts / rosemary / lemon glaze

Monster Mash

gluten-free oats / peanut butter / M&M’s / semi-sweet chocolate / raisins

Pick of the Patch

NEW FOR OCTOBER!

pumpkin / toffee bits / butterscotch / caramel / streusel topping

Cereal Killer

LAST CALL

Fruit Loops / Fruity Pebbles / marshmallows / Corn Flakes / Rice Krispies / marshmallow frosting

Chocolate Diablo

NEW FOR OCTOBER!

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cayenne pepper / crushed red pepper / cinnamon / paprika

Caramel Apple Crisp

oats / granny smith apples / white chocolate / toffee bits / cinnamon / salted caramel / streusel

Cookie Dough

BACK IN STOCK!

sugar cookie base / milk chocolate chips / cookie dough frosting

Frosted Classic Cups

semi-sweet chocolate / sea salt / vanilla cream cheese frosting

Sch'mores

honey graham base / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted marshmallow

PB & J

peanut butter / grape or strawberry jelly / peanut butter chips / roasted peanuts

Mocha Java

dark cocoa / cocoa nibs / white chocolate / semisweet chocolate / espresso frosting

PB Remix

peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / chocolate frosting / fluffer frosting

Dirty Peppermint

dark cocoa / peppermint bits / cream cheese frosting

Eggnog

gluten free sugar base / eggnog frosting / cinnamon

Glazed Pistachio

chopped pistachios / white chocolate / sweet almond glaze

Mexican Hot Chocolate

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cinnamon / cayenne pepper / powdered sugar

The Graceland

bacon / peanut butter / banana / semi-sweet chocolate

Blueberry Cobbler

LAST CALL

oats / blueberries / white chocolate / cinnamon / lemon glaze / streusel

Strawberries & Cream

LAST CALL

strawberries / white chocolate / strawberry glaze

Black & Tan

dark cocoa / Guinness / semi-sweet chocolate / Guinness frosting

Schmackaroni & Cheese

corn flour / cornmeal / cheddar / gruyere / mozzarella / bacon / elbow macaroni

The Great White Way

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / macadamia nuts

White Island

LAST CALL – Limited Stock

white chocolate / macadamia nuts / sweetened coconut

Lemon Poppy

LAST CALL

corn flour / lemon / poppyseed / sweet lemon glaze

Red, White, & Blueberry

✔Back in July!

oats / blueberries / cranberries / Montmorency tart cherries / white chocolate

The Super "C"

“Candy Coated Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie”
Holiday M&M’s / white chocolate / sea salt

Fluffer Nutter

peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / peanut butter-marshmallow frosting

Caramel Delight

✔Back in July!

dark cocoa / sweetened coconut / English toffee / salted caramel

Schmacker - doodle

cinnamon / sugar / cinnamon chips / cinnamon sugar chunks

Cotton Candy

sweet sugar base / tofu cream cheese / cotton candy butter cream frosting

Piña Colada

pineapple / sweetened coconut / white rum

Bacon Chocolate Chip

semi-sweet chocolate / bacon / sea salt

The Birthday Party

LAST CALL – Limited Stock

cake batter cookie / sprinkles / cream cheese / Oreos / semisweet & white chocolate

Hibiscus Passionfruit

hibiscus / strawberry / passionfruit glaze

Honey Bunches

oats / honey / granola clusters / toasted almonds / plump raisins

Buckeye Moonpie

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / peanut butter-marshmallow frosting

Butter Pecan

browned butter / toasted pecans / butterscotch

Banana Split

banana / strawberry / pineapple / nutella

Chocolate Covered Strawberry

semi-sweet chocolate / strawberries

Dirty Leprechaun

dark cocoa / mint chips / semisweet chocolate

Earl of Chocolate

semi-sweet chocolate / earl grey / candied orange peel

Ginger Rogers

molasses / ginger / white chocolate / cinnamon chips / cinnamon / cloves / black pepper / sweet sugar glaze

PB Banana Crunch

✔Back in July!

peanut butter / roasted peanuts / banana chips / sea salt

Cranberry Dream

oats / dried cranberries / white chocolate chunks / cinnamon / lemon glaze

White Chocolate Cherry Chunker

white chocolate / montmorency tart cherries / oats / cinnamon

Chunky Monkey

oatmeal / banana / semi-sweet chocolate / walnuts

Almond Roca

English toffee / toasted almonds / semisweet chocolate drizzle

Rocky Road

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted almonds / roasted marshmallow

A Citrus Story

“You’ll Shoot Your Oats Out Kid!”
oats / cranberries / orange oil & zest / cinnamon chips / toasted pecans

Thai Chili Peanut

peanut butter / garlic / fresh ginger / Thai chili’s / sweet & spicy peanut glaze

Worms 'n Dirt

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate pudding / chocolate cream cheese frosting / oreo bits / gummy worms

Chocolate Covered Raspberry

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / raspberry puree / chocolate cream cheese frosting

Chocolate Lava

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate fudge / chocolate cream cheese frosting

Andy's Mint

dark cocoa / mint chips / semisweet chocolate / chocolate frosting

Schmackary's Cart

Sub Total $0.00