FIRST TIME? SAVE 15% YOUR FIRST ORDER WITH CODE ITSABOUTTIME 🍪 ORDER NOW!
Our Flavors
Over 75 Flavors and Counting
Flavors changing often! Be sure to try our "Last Call" flavors before they leave for the season!
Available This Week!
The Classic
semi-sweet chocolate / sea salt
Funfetti
sugar cookie base / rainbow sprinkles / vanilla cream cheese frosting
Cookies & Cream
dark cocoa / white chocolate / oreo bits / vanilla cream cheese frosting
Red Velvet
✔Back in September!
deep red cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / cream cheese frosting
Maple Bacon
LEAVING SOON!
candied bacon / maple syrup / toffee bits / sea salt
Oatmeal Scotchie
oats / butterscotch chips / cinnamon / vanilla
Yogi Bare
gluten free oats / peanut butter / applesauce / cranberries / almonds / sunflower seeds / pumpkin seeds / raisins / maple syrup / cinnamon
The Hummingbird
oats / pineapple / coconut / banana / toasted pecans / southern cream cheese frosting
Chocolate Duet
dark cocoa / white chocolate / semi-sweet chocolate / walnuts
Mystery Cookie
We select a mystery cookie to fill out your flight.
Sch'mores
honey graham base / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted marshmallow
@eatingnyc's Chocolate Crunch
LIMITED TIME FLAVOR
We’ve teamed up with IG’s @eatingnyc for this chocolate crunch cookie delight!
triple chocolate cookie / chocolate nutella frosting / sprinkles / crushed peanuts / sugar cone bits
Hibiscus Strawberry
LEAVING SOON!
hibiscus / cacao nibs / strawberry glaze (vegan)
Cookie Butter Bliss
BACK IN STOCK!
Biscoff cookie butter / brown sugar / cinnamon / vanilla
The Hangover
BACK IN STOCK!
potato chips / walnuts / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / butterscotch / m&ms / raisins / coconut / cinnamon / oats
Dulce de Leche
LEAVING SOON!
caramel fudge / dulce de leche / caramel bites / cinnamon
No Tricks, Just Treats
snickers / butterfinger / reeses pieces / peanut bits / caramel / toffee bits
Peanut Butter Cup
peanut butter / semi-sweet chocolate / roasted peanuts / sea salt
The Peanut Gallery
peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips
*may contain peanuts
Sweet Corn
corn flour / cornmeal / sweet corn / cranberries / pecan bits
Choconut Chip
semi-sweet chocolate / sweetened coconut / walnuts / sea salt
Chocolate Explosion
LEAVING SOON!
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate fudge frosting
Key Lime
LAST CALL – Limited Stock
key lime oil & zest / white chocolate / pistachios / graham cracker / lime cream cheese frosting
Mint Mojito
LAST CALL – limited Stock
corn flour / fresh mint leaves / lime oil / cuban rum glaze
Strawberry Rhubarb
LAST CALL – Limited Stock
strawberries / tart rhubarb / sour strawberry glaze
Carrot Cake
LEAVING SOON!
shredded carrots / sweetened coconut / walnuts / raisins / cinnamon / cream cheese frosting
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
LAST CALL!
dark cocoa / pretzel bits / semi-sweet chocolate / peanut butter chips / sea salt
Green Tea
LEAVING SOON!
matcha green tea / white chocolate / macadamia nuts / green tea glaze
Corny Cowboy
LAST CALL – Limited Stock
sweet corn kernels / bacon / cheddar cheese / diced jalepenos
Peanut Butter Patty
peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / chocolate frosting
Lucky Charmed
LEAVING SOON!
sugar / marshmallows / vanilla / milk & mallow frosting / Lucky Charms cereal
Caramel Apple Crisp
LEAVING SOON!
oats / granny smith apples / white chocolate / toffee bits / cinnamon / salted caramel / streusel
Treats Available Now!
Treats are not currently available. Coming back soon!
Out of Season
BLOOD Red Velvet
deep red cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / cream cheese frosting
*edible blood on local orders only
Candied Yam
NEW FOR OCTOBER!
corn flour / yams / toasted pecans / brown sugar / cinnamon / toasted marshmallow
Peanut Butter After Dark
NEW FOR OCTOBER!
dark cocoa / peanut butter cups / peanut butter chips / semi-sweet chocolate
Pumpkin Spice
NEW FOR OCTOBER!
pumpkin / autumnal spices / cranberries / cinnamon chips / pecans / maple cream cheese frosting
Rosemary's Baby
pine nuts / rosemary / lemon glaze
Monster Mash
gluten-free oats / peanut butter / M&M’s / semi-sweet chocolate / raisins
Pick of the Patch
NEW FOR OCTOBER!
pumpkin / toffee bits / butterscotch / caramel / streusel topping
Cereal Killer
LAST CALL
Fruit Loops / Fruity Pebbles / marshmallows / Corn Flakes / Rice Krispies / marshmallow frosting
Chocolate Diablo
NEW FOR OCTOBER!
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cayenne pepper / crushed red pepper / cinnamon / paprika
Caramel Apple Crisp
oats / granny smith apples / white chocolate / toffee bits / cinnamon / salted caramel / streusel
Cookie Dough
BACK IN STOCK!
sugar cookie base / milk chocolate chips / cookie dough frosting
Frosted Classic Cups
semi-sweet chocolate / sea salt / vanilla cream cheese frosting
Sch'mores
honey graham base / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted marshmallow
PB & J
peanut butter / grape or strawberry jelly / peanut butter chips / roasted peanuts
Mocha Java
dark cocoa / cocoa nibs / white chocolate / semisweet chocolate / espresso frosting
PB Remix
peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / chocolate frosting / fluffer frosting
Dirty Peppermint
dark cocoa / peppermint bits / cream cheese frosting
Eggnog
gluten free sugar base / eggnog frosting / cinnamon
Glazed Pistachio
chopped pistachios / white chocolate / sweet almond glaze
Mexican Hot Chocolate
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / cinnamon / cayenne pepper / powdered sugar
The Graceland
bacon / peanut butter / banana / semi-sweet chocolate
Blueberry Cobbler
LAST CALL
oats / blueberries / white chocolate / cinnamon / lemon glaze / streusel
Strawberries & Cream
LAST CALL
strawberries / white chocolate / strawberry glaze
Black & Tan
dark cocoa / Guinness / semi-sweet chocolate / Guinness frosting
Schmackaroni & Cheese
corn flour / cornmeal / cheddar / gruyere / mozzarella / bacon / elbow macaroni
The Great White Way
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / white chocolate / macadamia nuts
White Island
LAST CALL – Limited Stock
white chocolate / macadamia nuts / sweetened coconut
Lemon Poppy
LAST CALL
corn flour / lemon / poppyseed / sweet lemon glaze
Red, White, & Blueberry
✔Back in July!
oats / blueberries / cranberries / Montmorency tart cherries / white chocolate
The Super "C"
“Candy Coated Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie”
Holiday M&M’s / white chocolate / sea salt
Fluffer Nutter
peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / peanut butter-marshmallow frosting
Caramel Delight
✔Back in July!
dark cocoa / sweetened coconut / English toffee / salted caramel
Schmacker - doodle
cinnamon / sugar / cinnamon chips / cinnamon sugar chunks
Cotton Candy
sweet sugar base / tofu cream cheese / cotton candy butter cream frosting
Piña Colada
pineapple / sweetened coconut / white rum
Bacon Chocolate Chip
semi-sweet chocolate / bacon / sea salt
The Birthday Party
LAST CALL – Limited Stock
cake batter cookie / sprinkles / cream cheese / Oreos / semisweet & white chocolate
Hibiscus Passionfruit
hibiscus / strawberry / passionfruit glaze
Honey Bunches
oats / honey / granola clusters / toasted almonds / plump raisins
Buckeye Moonpie
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / peanut butter-marshmallow frosting
Butter Pecan
browned butter / toasted pecans / butterscotch
Banana Split
banana / strawberry / pineapple / nutella
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
semi-sweet chocolate / strawberries
Dirty Leprechaun
dark cocoa / mint chips / semisweet chocolate
Earl of Chocolate
semi-sweet chocolate / earl grey / candied orange peel
Ginger Rogers
molasses / ginger / white chocolate / cinnamon chips / cinnamon / cloves / black pepper / sweet sugar glaze
PB Banana Crunch
✔Back in July!
peanut butter / roasted peanuts / banana chips / sea salt
Cranberry Dream
oats / dried cranberries / white chocolate chunks / cinnamon / lemon glaze
White Chocolate Cherry Chunker
white chocolate / montmorency tart cherries / oats / cinnamon
Chunky Monkey
oatmeal / banana / semi-sweet chocolate / walnuts
Almond Roca
English toffee / toasted almonds / semisweet chocolate drizzle
Rocky Road
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted almonds / roasted marshmallow
A Citrus Story
“You’ll Shoot Your Oats Out Kid!”
oats / cranberries / orange oil & zest / cinnamon chips / toasted pecans
Thai Chili Peanut
peanut butter / garlic / fresh ginger / Thai chili’s / sweet & spicy peanut glaze
Worms 'n Dirt
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate pudding / chocolate cream cheese frosting / oreo bits / gummy worms
Chocolate Covered Raspberry
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / raspberry puree / chocolate cream cheese frosting
Chocolate Lava
dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate fudge / chocolate cream cheese frosting
Andy's Mint
dark cocoa / mint chips / semisweet chocolate / chocolate frosting
Schmackary's Cart
Sub Total $0.00
