Our Flavors

Over 100 Flavors and Counting

Flavors changing often! Be sure to try our "Last Call" flavors before they leave for the season!

Available This Week!


Butter, Sugar, Flour…
Plus mountains of sprinkles.
Topped with our famous frosting.

The Classic

Far from average, forever a classic,
Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks
and a hint of coarse sea salt.

Cookies & Cream

Oreos / Dark Cocoa / Homemade Vanilla Frosting

The Horny Unicorn

A burst of colorful joy! This magically
vibrant, swirled sugar cookie with hints
of almond will transport you to a land of
rainbows, glitter & sweet sugary delight.

Dulce de Leche

Abuela approved! This cookie is made
with homemade dulce de leche caramel
and dusted with cinnamon sugar.

Oatmeal Scotchie

This combination of oats, creamy
butterscotch, vanilla and a pinch of
cinnamon is practically perfection.

Yogi Bare

A cookie fit for the trail!
Brimming with peanut butter, oats,
raisins, craisins, nuts & seeds.

The Hummingbird

Oats, banana, pineapple, pecans,
and Southern cream cheese frosting.
So good you won’t believe its vegan!

Chocolate Duet

A beautiful harmony of cocoa with
notes of semisweet & white chocolate.
Walnut pieces add texture to this melody!


Taste the campfire with our honey graham
base, packed full of chocolate chunks
and topped with roasted marshmallow!

Cookie Butter Bliss

Cookie butter straight from the jar and
into a chewy delight with notes of warm
cinnamon. You’ll never believe its vegan!

Cereal Killer

Fruity Pebbles, Fruit Loops, Cornflakes
and loads of marshmallowy goodness.
Part of this complete dessert.

The Candy Bar

A sinfully rich chocolate base packed
with Snickers, Butterfinger, toffee bits,
Reese’s Pieces & salted caramel!

Peanut Butter Cup

Packed with semisweet chocolate and
loads of crunchy peanut butter, this
Schmackary’s classic is now Vegan!
It’s simply peanut butter bliss.

Sweet Corn

Inspired by Southern cornbread, this
Sweet + Savory combo, stuffed with
toasted pecans & cranberries pleases
even the most discerning taste buds.

Turtle Snaps


A teenage mutant ninja cookie!
Gobs of chewy caramel and semisweet
chocolate blend together with a crunch
of toasted pecans and a dash of sea salt.

Blueberry Cobbler

An oatmeal sensation with blueberries
and white chocolate, topped with
lemon glaze & cinnamon streusel.
“Violet, your’e turning violet, Violet!”

Key Lime

Taking this Floridian favorite up a notch
with crushed pistachios, white chocolate
and a lime zested vanilla frosting!

Chip of The Iceberg

NEW Flavor!

A crunchy blend of butterscotch, semisweet chocolate,

& white chocolate with Ruffles potato chips


White Island

White Chocolate + Macadamia Nut
and then add sweet coconut for texture!
When can I move to this island?!

Lemon Poppy

Soft & tender with a corn flour base
and drizzled with a sweet lemon glaze,
this cookie is like a taste of sunshine.

Fluffer Nutter

A peanut butter fantasy complete with
ground peanuts, peanut butter chips &
peanut butter marshmallow frosting.

Strawberry Rhubarb

A fruity, strawberry delight, plus fresh tart
rhubarb to give your tastebuds a zing!

Hibiscus Passionfruit

A tart, sweet & delicious treat!
With candied hibiscus and a tangy
passionfruit glaze to give your
tastebuds a zing!

Mystery Cookie

We select a random cookie to fill out your flight.

Treats Available Now!

Funfetti Cookie Cake

Our best selling Funfetti cookie is now a 5-tier Cookie Cake!
If you love a frosted sugar cookie, this cake will NOT disappoint!

3-Chip Schmackaroon

Not your Yenta’s Macaroons!

Butter Pecan Schmackaroon

Not your Yenta’s Macaroons!

Butterscotch Schmackaroon

Not your Yenta’s Macaroons!

Chocolate Dipped Schmackaroon

Not your Yenta’s Macaroons!

Chocolate Toffee Schmackaroon

Not your Yenta’s Macaroons!

White Chocolate Pistachio Schmackaroon

Treats are not currently available. Coming back soon!

Out of Season

& Juliet's Strawberry Rhubarb

& Juliet

This delightful cookie embodies the spirit of the show with its vibrant flavors and playful combination. We infuse the natural sweetness of ripe strawberries and pair it with the tangy twist of fresh rhubarb. The result is a harmonious blend of flavors that mirrors the dynamic and energetic storytelling of & Juliet. This whimsical treat will transport you to a world of love, adventure, and musical enchantment.

Spring Spirit


Straight from the bunny’s burrow, this
swirled pastel cookie, infused with
almond essence and edible glitter, will
bring a touch of magic to your basket!

The Amazin' Corn Bred Cookie


This corn-tastic cookie is a corn-credible treat that will leave you corn-pletely satisfied. This corn bread inspired cookie is infused with ear-resistibly fresh sweet corn, toasted pecans and dried cranberries. With each mouthful, you’ll be  transported to the heartland of Shucked, where corny jokes, delightful puns and incredible talent literally “pop” on stage.

Cookies & SCREAM

Cookies & Cream has gone GREEN for Wicked’s 20th Anniversary!

Black cocoa, Oreo cookie crumbs,
white chocolate & vanilla frosting.
An instant fan favorite.

Chocolate Cookie Crunch


A sinfully rich chocolate base covered

with fudgey chocolate frosting
and our signature rainbow crunch mix.

I Put A Spell On You

Just a bunch of Hocus Pocus loaded with
cocoa, semisweet chocolate and topped
with our fudgey chocolate frosting and
a special Sanderson Sister sprinkle blend!

Sugar Cookie Crunch

When they’re gone, they’re gone.

Where have Sugar Cookie M&Ms been
all my life?! These crispy crunchy gems
are packed inside a soft & chewy sugar
cookie with bits of white chocolate.

Wizards Brew

An enchanting blend of
rich butterscotch, caramel, and frothy
cream soda. A delightful treat for wizards
and everyday cookie-enthusiasts alike..

Spooky & Sweet

A burst of eerie enchantment!
This mysteriously vibrant, swirled sugar cookie,
is laced with haunting hints of almond,
ghostly glitter, and spine-tingling sugary delight.

Red Velvet

Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with
semisweet and white chocolate.
Finished with silky vanilla frosting.

The King of New York


Extra, Extra! A newsboy favorite, this chocolate covered pretzel cookie is a harmonious blend of sweet and salty flavors. Loaded with chocolate, peanut butter chips and crushed pretzel bits, it’s making headlines! With its irresistible combination of textures and tastes, this cookie is a delicious homage to the timeless charm of the Newsies musical.

Field of Dreams

A delicate blend of soothing lavender &
earl grey tea, swirling in perfect balance.
Softly intriguing, just like a whispered
secret at tea time.

Cherry Chunker

She’s chunky, funky and oh so delicious!
Montmorency tart cherries, creamy
white chocolate & a dash of cinnamon
make a simply oatrageous combination!

BLOOD Red Velvet

Rich and Velvety. Stuffed with
semisweet and white chocolate.
Finished with silky vanilla frosting.
*edible blood on local orders only

Maple Bacon

Maple candied bacon and homemade
toffee bits blended together for the
perfect savory/sweet snack.

Chocolate Cookie Crunch


Our chocolate crunch cookie is BACK!
triple chocolate cookie / chocolate nutella frosting / sprinkles / crushed peanuts / sugar cone bits

Sicilian Lemon

A soft & creamy lemon cookie with
a delicious blend of white chocolate,
pine nuts and fresh rosemary.

The Hangover

Oats, M&Ms, salt & vinegar chips,
coconut, butterscotch, nuts & more…
A cure for the roughest of nights!

Chocolate Diablo

Dark, decadent, smokey and spicy.
Each bite of this cookie with a kick
will take your mouth on a journey!

Peanut Butter Cup

Packed with mini peanut butter cups
and loaded with semisweet chocolate.
It’s simply peanut butter bliss.

The Peanut Gallery

peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips
*may contain peanuts

Caramel Apple Crisp

Granny Smith apples, white chocolate and gooey salted caramel. Finished with a dusting of cinnamon streusel.

Cookie Dough

A creamy cookie dough frosting tops this
milk chocolate laden sweet treat.
You cookie doughn’t want to miss this one!

The Great White Way

A blackout twist on the classic combo of
White Chocolate + Macadamia Nut
This cookie deserves a standing ovation!

The Monster

This Frankencookie is a graveyard smash
of oats, peanut butter, M&Ms and
semisweet chocolate chunks.

Choconut Chip

Take a classic and make it better!
Chocolate chunks, sweetened coconut &
walnut bits make this the ultimate chew!

Frosted Classic Cups

semi-sweet chocolate / sea salt / vanilla cream cheese frosting


honey graham base / semi-sweet chocolate / toasted marshmallow

PB & J

peanut butter / grape or strawberry jelly / peanut butter chips / roasted peanuts

Mocha Java

A dark chocolate cookie brewed with rich espresso, semisweet chocolate and crunchy cacao nibs. Finished off with our silky vanilla latte frosting.

PB Remix

peanuts / peanut butter / peanut butter chips / chocolate frosting / fluffer frosting

Dirty Peppermint

This cookie is on Santa’s naughty list.
Deep dark cocoa, crunchy peppermint
bits, smooth white chocolate and creamy
vanilla frosting is worth every sinful bite.


Your favorite holiday drink turned into
a soft & creamy cookie with
delicious hints of nutmeg and topped
with eggnog infused frosting.

The Graceland

A cookie fit for The King.
Peanut butter, semisweet chocolate,
banana, and bacon?!
A combo so weird, it has to be good.

Strawberries & Cream

Sun ripened strawberries paired
with creamy white chocolate! This
gluten-free gem is a sweet surrender
you wont soon forget.

Black & Tan

My Goodness, It’s Guinness!
The fudgiest of chocolate cookies gets
even better when paired with this boozy
cream cheese frosting.

Schmack & Cheese

Yeah, we put macaroni inside a cookie
along with crispy bacon and our own
4 cheese blend. A little sweet, mostly
savory, and 100% delicious!

Chocolate Explosion

A sinfully rich chocolate base loaded up
on semisweet chocolate and topped
with our fudgey chocolate frosting.

Devil's Food Cookie

NEW Flavor!

A fudgy chocolate cookie

slathered with smooth marshmallow frosting

topped with mini chocolate chips


PB & J


A timeless classic in every bite!

A chewy peanut butter throwback with hidden pockets of

strawberry jam and crunchy topping that will make you

go nutty!

Mint Mojito

A taste of Summer packed into a soft
sweet treat with muddled mint & lime.
Drizzled in a boozy rum glaze.

Caramel Delight

A chewy chocolate cookie with a blend
of sweet coconut flakes, toffee bits and
a smidge of caramel. What a delight!

Cinnamon Toasted Crunch

Taking kids cereal to places it’s never been before!
This new flavor is topped with milky marshmallow frosting
and a handful of delicious cinnamon squares.

Schmacker - doodle

Turning the snickerdoodle inside out
by stuffing it with cinnamon sugar
chunks and white chocolate

Glinda's Cotton Candy

“In honor of Glinda, and sure to be just as Popular!

This February, Schmackary’s has teamed up with Wicked to create

a sweet treat that could turn you vegan For Good.”

Carrot Cake

The perfect slice of Carrot Cake,
disguised as a soft, chewy cookie.
Roger Rabbit approved!

Chocolate Covered Pretzel

What goes together better than
chocolate and pretzels? This cookie
with peanut butter chips & sea salt.
There’s your answer.

Green Tea

Smooth organic matcha takes this
White Chocolate + Macadamia Nut
cookie to a whole new level.

Piña Colada

pineapple / sweetened coconut / white rum

Corny Cowboy

Southern cornbread with a kick!,
This Sweet + Savory combo is stuffed
with bacon, cheddar & jalapenos!
For the bucking bronco in you!

Bacon Chocolate Chip

Can a classic get any better?!
With a little bacon it can!
Salty, savory & sweet – all wrapped up
in this delicious treat!

Lucky Charmed

This cookie is magically delicious with
Lucky Charms cereal, marshmallows
and a milky marshmallow frosting.

The Birthday Party

Everyone is invited to this party!
A cake batter cookie complimented
with sprinkles, crushed oreos & two
varieties of chocolate!

Oatmeal Rum Raisin

Taking two classic flavors and marrying
them in sweet boozy bliss.
Rum-soaked raisins? Yes please!
We’re drunk with love for this one.

Pooh's Hunny Pot

oats / honey / toasted almonds / plump raisins

Honey Bunches

oats / honey / granola clusters / toasted almonds / plump raisins

Butter Pecan

Browned butter, plus butterscotch,
toffee bits and toasted pecan pieces.
I butter pecan’t with how good you are.

Banana Split

Filled with Strawberries, bananas,
pineapple and glazed in Nutella.
The only thing missing is ice cream!

Chocolate Covered Strawberry

Just like a ripened strawberry dipped
in decadent chocolate, this cookie will
take your tastebuds on a journey and
leave you begging for more!

Dirty Leprechaun


dark cocoa / mint chips / semisweet chocolate

Earl of Chocolate

Calm your senses with each bite. Earl
Grey tea, mixed with candied orange
peel and semisweet chocolate.

Ginger Rogers

The poetic blend of spices in this chewy
glazed ginger molasses cookie will have
your taste buds dancing cheek to cheek.

PB Banana Crunch

What the crunch?!
Creamy peanut butter gets chunky and
funky with crunchy banana chips.

Chunky Monkey


oatmeal / banana / semi-sweet chocolate / walnuts

Almond Roca

English toffee / toasted almonds / semisweet chocolate drizzle

Rocky Road

Embark on a journey of indulgence with decadent chocolate and toasted almonds and velvety marshmallow topping. A true symphony of flavors and textures in every bite.

A Citrus Story

“You’ll Shoot Your Oats Out Kid!”
oats / cranberries / orange oil & zest / cinnamon chips / toasted pecans

Thai Chili Peanut

peanut butter / garlic / fresh ginger / Thai chili’s / sweet & spicy peanut glaze

Poisoned Apple Crisp

Granny Smith apples, white chocolate
and gooey salted caramel. Finished
with a dusting of cinnamon streusel.

Worms 'n Dirt

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate pudding / chocolate cream cheese frosting / oreo bits / gummy worms

Chocolate Covered Raspberry

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / raspberry puree / chocolate cream cheese frosting

Chocolate Lava

dark cocoa / semi-sweet chocolate / chocolate fudge / chocolate cream cheese frosting

Andy's Mint

dark cocoa / mint chips / semisweet chocolate / chocolate frosting

Schmackary's Cart

Sub Total $0.00