FIRST TIME? SAVE 15% YOUR FIRST ORDER WITH CODE ITSABOUTTIME 🍪 ORDER NOW!
Make a Custom Flight Today!
From Caramel Apple Crisp to Carrot Cake, Hibiscus Passionfruit to Thai Chili Peanut, Maple Bacon to Worms ‘N Dirt, we guarantee you’ll find one to 75 reasons why we’re New York City’s Favorite Cookie Company!
Cookie Cakes
We are now serving tiered cookie cakes!
Imagine a stack of 5 cookies, layered with our sinful signature cream cheese frosting.
Perfect for that special someone. A gift so gorgeous, it’s almost a shame to eat it. Almost…
Check Out Our September Flavor Menu
Summer May Be Coming To A Close,
But Our Cookies Are Always In Season!
Check Out This Month’s Flavors Before They Disappear!
Check Out What's
Available In Store Today!
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
The Classic
Funfetti
Cookies & Cream
Red Velvet
Maple Bacon
Oatmeal Scotchie
Yogi Bare
The Hummingbird
Chocolate Duet
Mystery Cookie
@eatingnyc's Chocolate Crunch
Hibiscus Strawberry
Cookie Butter Bliss
Dulce de Leche
Sun
Mon
Tue
Wed
Thu
Fri
Sat
No Tricks, Just Treats
Peanut Butter Cup
The Peanut Gallery
Sweet Corn
Choconut Chip
Chocolate Explosion
Key Lime
Mint Mojito
Strawberry Rhubarb
Carrot Cake
Chocolate Covered Pretzel
Green Tea
Corny Cowboy
Peanut Butter Patty
Lucky Charmed
Caramel Apple Crisp
Schmackary's Cart
Sub Total $0.00
