Nationwide Ordering

We're literally here to send cookies to your mailbox

CookiesCookie CakesMerch

Please Note: We are a small, family-owned bakery operating with limited staff due to COVID-19 restrictions. Orders will be processed in the order they are received. Thanks for your patience.

Cookie 6-Packs

Baker's Choice

Let our Cookiologists take the guesswork
out of choosing the perfect 6-pack!
A perfectly curated box is on the way!


Oh So Classic

Far from average, forever a classic.
Packed with gourmet chocolate chunks
and a hint of coarse sea salt.


Fan Favorites

Try 6 of Our Best Selling Flavors!
Classic Chocolate Chip
Cookies & Cream


Frosted Fantasy

Sometimes you just need more frosting.
We’ve got you covered babe!
Enjoy a pack of this month’s frosted flavors.


Best Sellers

The Classic

semi-sweet chocolate / sea salt


sugar cookie base / holiday sprinkles / vanilla cream cheese frosting

Cookies & Cream

dark cocoa / white chocolate / oreo bits / vanilla cream cheese frosting

Oatmeal Scotchie

oats / butterscotch chips / cinnamon / vanilla

Spring flavors are HERE! Cookies make the best gifts for that special someone!

Build Your Own Dozen

Loading Cookies

Complete Your Gift

Heavenly Baked Gift Tin

Each Tin Holds 12 Old Fashioned Cookies or 25 Schmall Cookies


Doggone Good Cookies Tin

Each Tin Holds 12 Old Fashioned Cookies or 25 Schmall Cookies


A Schmackary's Original - The 5-Tier Cookie Cake

Funfetti Cookie Cake

Our best selling Funfetti cookie is now a 5-tier Cookie Cake!
If you love a frosted sugar cookie, this cake will NOT disappoint!


Cookies & Cream Cookie Cake

Oreos don’t hold a candle to this bad boy!
5 layers of Cookies & Cream cookies, filled with oreos and white chocolate. Covered and layered with our signature frosting and rolled in more Oreo crumbs.


Strawberry Short-Cookie Cake

Strawberry Short Cake has gone COOKIES!
5 Layers of our delicious Strawberry Rhubarb cookies filled and slathered in our homemade cream cheese frosting and topped with a Sweet Strawberry Glaze.


Candy Bar Cookie Cake

Our fantastically decadent Candy Bar cookies are now available as a 5-tiered cake!
You’ll find Snickers, Butterfinger, Reeses Pieces, caramel and english toffee surprises throughout and then topped with chocolate frosting and ooey gooey salted caramel.


Schmackary's Cart

Sub Total $0.00